How strange, try a single Titan too. And some different RAM if possible.

And give the drivers a clean with DDU in Safe Mode, between changing GFX Cards.

Which driver are you using now? The 327.23 WHQL or the new 331.40 BETA?

Also have a look in the BIOS for PCI-E settings and make sure they are set for PCI-E Gen 3.0 for the TITAN Slots.